Wednesday, January 25, 2017

Is it time to change my mind on technology class?

In my role as Technology Coordinator at a k-8 school I have been pretty adamant about one topic.

For the last 10 years I have insisted that we not have a technology curriculum and that we not have separate technology classes. I believed that all teaching of technology should be integrated within the regular classroom.

I believed this for a number of reasons:

  • Any technology skill we taught in elementary school would be entirely out of date by the time a student would actually need it. 
  • Teaching a skill in isolation, without context, is a poor way of teaching. Student retention was low.
  • Teaching how to use any specific piece of software was a bad idea as the software would be different within a couple of years.
  • It was better to teach a skill at the moment it was needed. For example: If you were about to have students complete their final draft of an essay or creative writing piece that was when you would teach word processing skills not two years prior.
I've been reading and watching and listening to what other schools have been doing lately and I wonder if my position is now wrong. 

Here are the things that have made me question my stance on this topic:
  • Digital Citizenship has become very important at the k-8 level. Students at my school are showing up with phones and data plans by grade 5. iPods are everywhere and we've gone 1-1 in grades 7 and 8. Our students need these skills now.
  • Coding. Is fluency or at least familiarity with coding becoming more important?
  • Lagging teacher skills. Is the average classroom teacher struggling to keep up with the rapidly changing technological landscape and therefore is there an increasing need for a specialist teacher to teach these skills?
I don't quite know the answer. I would love to hear your thoughts and ideas on the topic.

4 comments:

  1. We are integrating Chromebooks into our regular classroom teaching as of Kindergarten. We are 'teaching' keyboarding from Kindergarten to Grade 2 because the students are needing those skills by grade 3. I have not really seen the need for coding yet (we offer it as a high school course but have had no interest for several years). Lagging teacher skills is a HUGE issue. We have a few teachers moving forward, but far too many are far behind their students and are not really interested in catching up ('it is too much effort and things keep changing too quickly'). There is much more work that needs to happen in that area.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree teacher skill is a challenge. And yet I was celebrating yesterday as a team of my fellow teachers has been busy over the last week learning a new piece of software, problem solving, and getting ready for a PD event this Friday. They did all of this and never once approached me for help. (They did approach our technicians, but that's what we hired them for!) What's more, I have no idea how to use what they are using as I haven't had time to learn it. Even we as tech coordinators are struggling to keep up. Where once I would have known every single piece of software in the school inside and out, now I don't and can't.

      There are no easy solutions.

      Delete
  2. I like exposing my 3/4 class to coding so that they can recognize the opportunities that arise in the following years even if no other teacher does any tech with them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That is a great idea! The challenge I'm wondering about is the fact that not all teachers can do that. So is it time to bring back the dedicated technology class in order to teach a topic like coding? Is it becoming critical that we make it a set part of the curriculum?

      Delete